FORT WORTH, Texas — After the tragic mass shooting in El Paso, Roman Catholic Archbishop Gustavo Garcia-Siller of San Antonio lashed out at President Donald Trump.

In a series of now-deleted tweets, he called Trump “a very poor man” and urged him to “stop hate and racism, starting with yourself.”

His response was emotional; the senseless killings first in El Paso and then in Dayton, Ohio, have left many people in a state of confusion and anger.

Cynthia M. Allen mug

Cynthia M. Allen

But another screed squarely blaming Trump for the attacks is the last thing Americans need right now, especially from a religious leader.

Hurling such accusations, however founded they may be, fuels hatred at a time when emotions are extremely high.

And it allows all of us to shirk responsibility in contributing to the culture and environment that has made these kinds of mass shootings not only possible but increasingly common: a culture of narcissism, nihilism and death.

Another Catholic leader, Archbishop Charles Chaput of Philadelphia — who, not coincidentally, presided over the funerals of several victims of the Columbine massacre 20 years ago — described it this way: “The people using the guns in these loathsome incidents are moral agents with twisted hearts. And the twisting is done by the culture of sexual anarchy, personal excess, political hatreds, intellectual dishonesty, and perverted freedoms that we’ve systematically created over the past half-century.”

That’s a hard truth to swallow, and one that plenty of people will disagree with, because it doesn’t allow for easy answers and patchwork policy solutions — ban “assault weapons,” fix mental health care, impeach Trump — as if these things alone (or even in combination) will provide the immediate and permanent solutions our broken world demands.

And it makes us all complicit — if not active participants — in what The New York Times’ Ross Douthat describes as “our late-modern anti-culture, our internet-accelerated dissolution of normal human bonds.”

Indeed, it’s true that some people bear more responsibility than others in fomenting our current environment. Political leaders, with their bully pulpits and millions of Twitter followers, have a greater obligation than you or I to police our words and actions.

The duty to show restraint begins at the top — Trump gets no absolution here — but its frequent absence in the president is not an invitation for other public figures, or even ourselves, to follow suit.

Yet we accept it, even champion it, when it fulfills our own personal or political prejudices.

Consider that not one of Trump’s Democratic political challengers has resisted the opportunity to use the president’s real or imagined role the tragedy as a means to raise money and score political points.

The brother (and also the campaign chairman) of Democratic presidential candidate Julian Castro went so far as to tweet the names and employers of people in his district who had donated the legal maximum to Trump’s re-election campaign. It appears to be an effort to link them to the El Paso shooting — and let’s be honest, to generate harassment of and potentially other hardships for them.

That sounds like something Trump and his minions would do: reduce people to the lowest common denominator. Ally or enemy. Criminal or “very fine” person. Convenience or inconvenience.

That sounds like a world, as Chaput writes, that “markets violence,” promotes “selfishness and greed,” and enshrines “certain kinds of killing” in law.

In that sense, Trump isn’t the cause of the “dark psychic force of the collectivized hatred” as Democratic presidential candidate Marianne Williamson would have it. That force has been building for decades on social media, in Washington, in the troubled minds of disaffected people all over the country.

Trump is just its current champion, its low-hanging fruit.

The world the cultivated the El Paso and Dayton, and Gilroy and Tree of Life and Charleston shooters existed before Trump.

Immediately removing Trump from the equation wouldn’t stop it or even slow it down.

And without profound cultural transformation that revolutionizes the way we perceive and treat every human being — from birth to natural death — it will continue to flourish after he is a distant, ugly memory.

Subscribe to Breaking News

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Cynthia M. Allen is a columnist for the Fort Worth Star-Telegram. Readers may send her email at cmallen@star-telegram.com.


(11) comments


You mean the ones that make our furniture in Arcadia, pluck our chickens, work on our houses and other construction? People that have families here, lives here, that will have to wait 20 years just to get citizenship because of new policies by your POTUS?

They're such horrible people. Lets build walls that won't work and mow them down with machine gun drones at the border.


JD - I have no problem with legal immigration. We take in 1 Million legal immigrants every year.. it’s the 1 Million illegal immigrants a year I have issues with.


Nice, that might be the smartest thing you done here that I ever seent. Trying to cover all your bases. Smooth... Too bad your history on immigrants says differently.

*drone machine gun fire rattles on in the distance*


Bruce - What about the culture that devalued life by legalizing abortion?

For the record I denounce White Supremacy, the KKK and any other hate group.


But you support tRump who supports white nationalism, racism, David Duke, and the KKK. You do not get to have it both ways.


Incorrect Khansky. That is another ignorant misnomer about the democrats that republicans espouse. The parties switched sides over time.


Amongst MANY other articles on the subject matter.

Yet another idiot republican not knowing what he's talking with. But with you Khansky, that's no surprise at at all. Even Bo is light years ahead of you. Which is sadder than anything I can imagine...


Bruce +1

Bruce Montplaisir

Cynthia Allen is correct that culture created the El Paso shooter. The culture that created the El Paso shooter is made up of people excusing white supremacists and the Ku Klux Clan, which was revived by conservative evangelicals. The implication by Allen that Trump didn’t have anything to do with creating the El Paso shooter is kind of implying that a member of a crew building a building has nothing to do with putting up the building because it is the construction crew that put up the building. The Catholic Church leaders were very supportive of the Trump campaign, knowing what kind of a person he has been for decades. Articles advising Catholics to “Vote Right” appeared in Catholic publications prior to the 2016 election. The idea that Trump would change the language and behavior he has used and demonstrated for decades, once he became president, seems at odds with catholic marriage counselors who tell people they probably will not be able to change their fiancée once they are married.


And then there are presidents, who lie through their teeth, with words prophesying, if you like your Dr. or health plan, you can keep it.

As a point of history, through the years, the Democrats were the supporters of so called 'white supremacy' & the KKK,

Bruce Montplaisir

And there are presidents who lie 10 to 15 times a day, every day, all day long. At some point in history it may well be true that democrats supported white supremacy and the KKK however the people supporting those organizations have always been conservatives wanting to conserve a past history that worked to their advantage.


We reap, and never learn...duh! We get only what we deserve...! Duh!

Cannot pass on what we do not know!!!!!!!!!!

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.