Catherine Rampell: Hating big government -- until measles hit

Catherine Rampell: Hating big government -- until measles hit

  • 1

Americans love, love, love to hate on government, for all its foibles and failures.

But we conveniently forget that good government has also solved, curtailed or prevented a lot of problems over the years, including epidemics, economic ills and environmental crises.

When government works, it becomes largely invisible, taken for granted, wiping out both crises and the traumatic memories of those crises.

Catherine Rampell mug

Catherine Rampell

Bad government we remember and loathe and curse to our children; but good government is often a victim of its own success, the cure so effective that we forget how horrifying the ailment it eradicated was.

That has been quite literally true when it comes to public-health crises once thought consigned to history, such as the current measles outbreak.

Nearly two decades ago, measles was declared eliminated from the United States.

This achievement was due to good science, yes. (Researchers developed a vaccine in the 1960s.) But we can also credit good government policy, as jurisdictions around the country began subsidizing and ultimately mandating childhood immunization.More recently, this highly contagious and potentially fatal disease has returned, ravaging communities around the country. Since January, 940 individual cases of measles have been confirmed across 26 states, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.The far right’s response to this outbreak, bizarrely, has been an outcry for government to ... butt out.

Some of these calls are motivated by pseudoscience linking vaccines to autism (a link that was long ago debunked, though still propagated by conspiracy theorists on both the left and right, including President Trump). Lately, more have been motivated by libertarian zealotry.A “Liberty Loving Republican” Texas lawmaker recently referred to vaccines as “sorcery” and compared government-mandated inoculation to communism. The Republican governor of Kentucky likewise said policies mandating vaccination are un-American; one of the U.S. senators from his state, Rand Paul (R), echoed that government-required immunizations are a threat to “liberty,” even though he’s a physician who should know better.

In other states where officials are trying to tighten vaccination requirements, including Maine, Washington, Colorado and Oregon, “nearly all of the opponents are Republicans who’ve taken a medical freedom stance,” as Politico noted in a recent article.

In California — where 900 students on two college campuses were recently quarantined — every single Republican state senator opposed a recent measure cracking down on immunization exemptions.

Thankfully — at least for the time being — these outbreaks appear mostly contained, a credit to the herd immunity developed by decades of mandatory vaccinations.

But that false sense of security has only emboldened those ideologues to proclaim that perhaps we don’t need the very government policies that reduced the threat.

There are parallels to other social or economic ills that threaten to come roaring back in the years ahead, as anti-government fanatics take advantage of fading memories.Consider, for instance, the recent Republican attacks on the Federal Reserve.

Beginning with Paul Volcker’s ascension to the chairmanship 40 years ago, the central bank cultivated a reputation for independence and a willingness to do things that were politically unpopular. This reputation is exactly what enabled the Fed to break the back of inflation and to credibly commit to stable prices in the decades since.Americans have been spoiled by this impressive policy achievement, however. And we have now forgotten why the bank’s autonomy was worth safeguarding in the first place.

Or consider ongoing attempts to roll back environmental regulations, including limits on the pollutants that can be dumped into our air or waterways. Such bureaucratic red tape isn’t necessary, Trump and his cronies suggest, because U.S. environmental quality is already top-notch.

Even if we did hold some sort of planetary record — which we don’t — the reason pollution has been declining is precisely because of these same laws and regulations that Trump wants to dismantle.Acid rain, flaming rivers and choking smog have abated thanks to deliberate policy choices this country has made over the years, and that Trump is now trying to unmake. If anything, the environmental and public-health crises that remain — including in Flint, Michigan — suggest our government has done too little to protect its citizens, rather than too much.

An ancient Chinese book of strategy advises using your enemy’s strength against him. Clearly the anti-government right has taken this advice to heart.

Washington Post columnist Catherine Rampell can be reached at


Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

President Donald Trump has finally goaded Twitter into starting the fight that Trump has been itching to have. Unfortunately for the social media giant, it's a fight Twitter cannot win anymore - and one that Trump and his allies do not want to end. Over the course of his term, the president has flouted Twitter's terms of service countless times with impunity as he's used the platform to launch ...

Will your neighborhood school open on schedule in the fall? The answer should vary by location, but some headline-grabbing declarations are prolonging the uncertainty for families and students. And uncertainty leads to fear - an infectious state of mind best treated with a dose of common sense. Special-interest groups encouraged educators to "scream bloody murder" if collective bargaining and ...

It has often occurred to me that the appropriate response to some of the ridiculous things President Donald Trump utters is: "He's an idiot." Don't get me wrong (as op-ed writers like to say). I'm not impugning Trump's IQ. By "idiot" I mean something a bit different: that Trump often doesn't know what he's talking about. (That doesn't exclude the possibility that some of his misrepresentations ...

As a child, I grew up in abject poverty with our family being evicted often. A number of times I found myself in a poor African American neighborhoods or public housing. During those times, I was often the only white child in my class. I can say in total honesty, I was never happier as a child than when I was in those neighborhoods, housing projects or those classrooms. Ever. During the rare ...

In July 2001, a 28-year-old woman named Lori Klausutis fell and hit her head on a desk at work in Fort Walton Beach, Fla. She was found dead the next morning. The medical examiner concluded that there was no foul play, and it later turned out that Klausutis had an undiagnosed heart condition. There would be no reason today to publicly discuss this tragic accident, but for the fact that ...

He isn't trending right now, but he should be. Still, it didn't take long for savvy social media mavens to make the connection between banished NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick, who was blacklisted after taking a knee against police brutality, and Derek Chauvin, the Minneapolis cop who was fired after taking a knee on a black man's neck. The two images side by side say everything that needs to ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News