WSU professors say environmental risks of mining exposed sandstone are limited — but do exist

2012-09-20T00:00:00Z 2013-02-14T12:27:18Z WSU professors say environmental risks of mining exposed sandstone are limited — but do existBy Alexandria Fisher Winona Daily News

There’s more to frac sand mining than what’s on the surface.


Members of Winona State University’s geology department discussed the geology of frac sand and its relation to Winona and larger areas Wednesday as part of WSU’s athenaeum series.

“We wanted to provide context to the whole sand issue that’s been affecting our area,” said geoscience professor Toby Dogwiler.

The Jordan and St. Peter sandstones laid down hundreds of millions of years ago and the source of the hard, round, uniform sand grains prized by oil and natural gas drillers, underlie much of the region, Dogwiler explained. However, these sandstone layers are covered by and sandwiched among layers of limestone, shale, silt, clay and soil — making all but a very small portion accessible to frac sand miners.

The only areas where mining is economically feasible are  in the valleys, where natural forces or erosion have exposed the sandstone, he said.

And a number of additional factors further limit the locations where mining is likely to occur, like limitations on mining on  publicly owned lands, laws protecting streams, transportation costs, land reclamation costs and other factors.

The mining process, however, does not come without side effects.

“There’s no doubt it will affect groundwater resources,” Dogwiler said. “What it boils down to is not if there’s frac sand mining but how much.”

Frac sand is used in hydraulic fracturing, a relatively new method of mining oil and natural gas deposits in other parts of the country by using pressurized water, sand, and chemicals.

“With oil prices going up, gas prices going up, this has become more economically feasible,” said WSU geoscience professor Candace Kairies-Beatty.

Many area residents have expressed concerns about the potential impacts of frac sand mining, including increased truck traffic, health and environmental risks, and destruction of the landscape.

“We have a lot of what they want,” said Winona resident Sarah Joy. “And they’re obviously going full stream ahead to get that.”

Dogwiler said that while there may be limited environmental risks in mining exposed sandstone, that doesn’t mean they don’t exist.

“The science of this is pretty clear,” he said, but added: “Just because you have good science doesn’t mean you’re going to use it to make good decisions.”

Copyright 2015 Winona Daily News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(2) Comments

  1. LaCrosse Honda
    Report Abuse
    LaCrosse Honda - September 20, 2012 8:53 am
    The Minnesota City Kwik Trip station will begin offering compressed natural gas as early as late November.*

    Interested in learning more about natural gas vehicles? Join us for Power in the Park this Saturday. Chris Schneider, hybrid guru, will host a short NGV discussion in four communities: Lanesboro, Stewartville, St. Charles & Winona.

    Power in the Park 9/22/12:

    *Minnesota City Kwik Trip story:
  2. Sonny
    Report Abuse
    Sonny - September 20, 2012 7:58 am
    Hydraulic fracturing has been around since the 40's. That doesn't seem "relatively new" to me.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick