Tim4Trout wrote on Mar 4, 2008 4:32 PM:
" Since when has it been established that a species must be overpopulated or a nuisance for hunting to be justified? It should also be noted that the hsus opposes dove hunting even if there were problems.
Hsus claims of doves being "at their lightest weight" during hunting (not shooting) season are ludicrous and goes against the principles of nature. Minnesota's 2008 dove season occurs from early September to late October when both farmed and naturally occurring crops are maturing and when most species are eating to build up energy reserves in preparation for upcoming migration and/or hibernation. Related hsus claims also have doves reproducing which requires ample food for their offspring. One would be foolish to believe that other species are gaining weight during this time of bounty, but not doves.
Dove hunting provides both income for rural communities and critical funding for wildlife conservation.
"
Rawhide wrote on Mar 4, 2008 4:03 PM:
" I am in PETA as well. "People Eating Tasty Animals". Lady, you don't want to hunt, don't. You don't want to eat meat, don't. But don't foist your veiws on me. Thanks for making me aware of this stupid bill though. I have something else to discuss during my weekly emails to Rpes and Pellowski. "
Jack Sparrow wrote on Mar 4, 2008 9:31 AM:
" Doubling the length of the deer season will not do any good. People don't harvest their limit of deer as it is, which is why our area is so overpopulated. There are a few new regulations going into effect, mostly making the rules easier to comprehend. The all-season license has been eliminated, and now people can just buy each license (archery, 3A OR 3B, and muzzleloader). Also, the second weekend will be added back to the 3A season, either this year or next year, and the early doe season will continue in October. With any luck, these changes will cause less confusion, and hopefully will bring about a few more chanages to bring our deer population back down to where it should be. "
Hot Rod Otis wrote on Mar 4, 2008 8:23 AM:
" I agree with Ms. Fritz. They should instead double the length of the deer season. "
NorCal Cazadora wrote on Mar 4, 2008 8:20 AM:
" Excellent points, Kcodea and Jack. It's a little disturbing to see these statements without attribution to scientific studies by neutral parties.
Where's your evidence about doves being shredded to inedibility? I have a freezer full of them, and they're all fine.
Where's your evidence of most hunters not eating the doves they shoot? All the hunters I know get pretty excited about their dove recipes during dove season.
Where's your evidence of birds being poisoned?
This is just more propaganda from an organization that would force vegetarianism on the nation. I trust the readers of this newspaper are smart enough to see that, being the same citizens who passed a constitutional amendment protecting their hunting and fishing rights.
I'm wondering: What campaign will HSUS use to convince lions and hawks and wolves to stop eating meat? Can't wait to hear how that goes. "
kcodea wrote on Mar 4, 2008 7:09 AM:
" Thank you Jack Sparrow for debunking a good portion of this propoganda, but what still needs to be put forward is this lady's credentials. The Humane Society of the US is not the cat and dog shelters we all think of when we hear the words "humane society." That is something different. This lady's group is actually an animal rights group, much in the vein of PETA, that chose a name that often confuses and in many cases gives them instant credibility among unsuspecting readers. I think Winona Daily News readers should know this, and am a little suprised it wasn't made clear as this diatribe was granted a guest editorial designation. (at leaset on the website) "
Jack Sparrow wrote on Mar 4, 2008 1:33 AM:
" I'm sorry to say Ms. Fritz, but you are mistaken on many points in this article.
Most dove hunters eat their game. Dove is delicious.
The range doves are shot at leaves all the meat on the bird, especially since they tend to be shot from behind, saving the breast meat.
While doves in our area do not pose a threat to crops, in other areas of the country they do. Louisiana, for example, has (or used to have) a high dove population that did quite a bit of damage to their crops.
I am also curious where this "30% wounding rate" comes from.
It is pretty hard (not impossible, everyone makes mistakes) to mistake a kildeer for a mourning dove, since they make completely different sounds, and look drastically different.
"