Click here to view Winona Area Weather
Home > Opinion > Our Views > Story
 Advertisement 

SECTION SPONSORS


Published - Tuesday, May 08, 2007
POST COMMENT | READ COMMENTS (23 comment(s))

OUR VIEW: It’s time to pass medical marijuana

.
To hear some Republican legislators talk, Minnesota might as well start putting heroin in milk and open a methadone clinic on every street corner. A new law in the Legislature has created quite a little rhetoric by some politicians who worry that legalizing marijuana for medical use would throw open the door to drugs.

Really, Minnesota would join 12 other states in making medical marijuana legal. What that means is that those with a marijuana card would be held immune from state prosecution for possession or use of the drug, while the federal authorities could, if they chose, still prosecute those who possess marijuana, a violation of federal drug law.
A slim majority of Senate lawmakers have chosen common sense over rhetoric and done the right thing by passing a medical marijuana bill. Our two local senators, Sharon Erickson Ropes and Steve Murphy, both voted in favor of the humane law.

As we live longer, we are faced with more terminal diseases that take life one miserable piece at a time rather than suddenly. That means that palliative care — or managing pain — is going to become more and more essential in our society. Marijuana for medical purposes has that kind of potential.

For those who argue that marijuana’s prevalence in our society will only result in more children and adults becoming addicted, we’ve got news for you: Marijuana is already commonplace in our communities. Medical marijuana’s impact on the streets of Minnesota will most likely be negligible because those who need it aren’t doing it for a high; it’s not an illicit drug to them. It’s something to be used, like a prescription or aspirin — something to make them feel better.

For too long, opponents of the medical marijuana debate have confused it with the War on Drugs. But medical marijuana has nothing to do with illicit drug use. This is about using the drug for palliative care. It’s no different than prescription pain killers that can be and often are abused.

It seems unfair — even cruel — to ban marijuana from those who might use it to have a life that’s more pain free just because of the potential for abuse by a few. We must think of the good that will be served by those who will use it for legitimate medical purposes and prosecute those who obtain it illegally.

We hope the Minnesota House will follow suit and pass a similar bill.

Gov. Tim Pawlenty has threatened to veto this bill because he believes it will make it harder for law enforcement officers to do their jobs.

While we don’t think a police officer’s job should be any harder, we also trust their professional judgment to determine the difference between illicit use and medical use. We wish the governor would give the law enforcement community a

little more credit. And we wish the governor would support legislation that would help demonstrate that compassionate and conservative are more than just words in a party slogan.

We hope that someday the need for medical marijuana will end. That would mean that medical science has eliminated chronic, painful and debilitating diseases. But that day isn’t here now. For now, there’s compassion and maybe soon, there’ll be medical marijuana in Minnesota.

The Winona Daily News editorial board also includes publisher Rusty Cunningham and online editor Jerome Christenson. To comment, call 453-3522 or send e-mail to letters@winonadailynews.com.
.
More News:
    Advertisement
     Tell us what you think...

     Comments »

    HIPPEECHIK wrote on Jun 9, 2007 1:37 AM:

    " LETS NOT FORGET, WHEN 1 HAS A TERMINAL &/OR DEBILITATING DISEASE OR DISABILITY, ONE OF THE MOST COMMON ISSUES WE DEAL WITH IS DEPRESSION. SORRY, BUT FOR ME ITS ALL EASIER TO LIVE & DEAL WITH MY LIMITATIONS AND ALL THE STRESS AND DIFFICULTY OF GOING ON, IF I'M STONED!!! I AM A SINGLE MOTHER OF 3, AGES 6, 8 & 9, ALL GIRLS. I HAVE MS & 1 OF MY BIGGEST PROBLEMS IS GETTING MY LEFT LEG TO WORK AND MY BALANCE, OR SHALL I SAY, IMBALANCE, ECSPECIALLY IN THE HEAT!! I'VE BEEN CALLED A DRUNK ON MORE THAN 1 OCCASION DUE TO MY GIMP. WHY NOT BE HIGH WHILE I'M DEALING WITH THE IGNORANCE OF THOSE WHO JUST DON'T KNOW ANY BETTER?! , BESIDES, ISN'T FUNCTIONING & FEELING BETTER THE WHOLE GOAL?! "

    hydaowen wrote on Jun 6, 2007 1:52 PM:

    " I'm an Oregon medical cannabis patient and an infantry veteran who suffers from chronic pain. I can tell you with strictest certainty that the decisions made by voters and legislators in my own state have made a huge difference in my quality of life. Medical marijuana allows those, like myself, who suffer severe side-effects to commercially produced pharmaceuticals to relieve symptoms associated with not only pain, but a variety of diseases and conditions. Several of these afflictions can be as difficult to treat as they are serious. Medical marijuana not only alleviates symptoms of horrible diseases like cancer and multiple sclerosis, but it has recently been shown to attack damaging cells. No other drug has so many beneficial effects, with so few potential risks, and yet it is federally regulated on par with heroin, cocaine, and crystal methamphetamine. Temporary euphoria as a side-effect does not equate to inherent evil. "

    serj wrote on May 20, 2007 10:07 AM:

    " it makes me tear up thinking how i can be prosecuted for using a substance as benign as cannabis to relieve post-traumatic stress disorder in this country. oh wait, that'd be legal if i was in california. now i'm all confused. "

    fredamae on deaths annually wrote on May 9, 2007 9:22 AM:

    " Prescription Drugs Adverse Reactions 106,000 Illegal Drugs All Illicit Drug Use 17,000 Caffeine, Alcohol and Tobacco Alcohol-Related=101,000 Tobacco-Related=435,000 536,000 Over-the-Counter Aspirin and other NSAID’s 17,000 Dietary Supplements Ephedra and other stimulants 155 cannabis 0 (zero) "

    Carl in California wrote on May 9, 2007 2:52 AM:

    " Thank you for publishing your views on medical marijuana. Let me tell you a little of myself and my personal experiences. First, I am a medical marijuana user in California. The powers that be hate to admit what a sensational success protected use of this medicinal plant has been and is. I am a disabled person and survive on my monthly SSI check. Most people would consider me poor. I live with constant pain that is alleviated by medicine that I no longer have to buy on the street. I do not cost the taxpayers money for prescriptions that tear down my health further, costing more money to the taxpayer attempting to reverse drug side effects. Do you see where this is heading? Long story short, I had to pay my doctor cash for a medical recommendation because this wasn't a covered service. I am not complaining because I view the recommendation at my "get out of jail free card". Does anyone see how ridiculous the persecution of this quite valuable plant is? Do the God fearing folks read Genesis regarding God's gift of the plants? The use of the plants? I'm not going to go quoting verses but do they think God made some sort of mistake with marijuana? Conservatives (of which I viewed myself as being one) need to wake up. I'm sure some think my view is lame. May I say that the western states have shown that medical marijuana has real value. Some places crime goes down. Revenue to the states is going up. California has already enjoyed many additional medical marijuana tax dollars and now our state board that collects sales tax says that they will accept tax dollars on the sale of marijuana. Smart thinking. Imagine how that income can be put to use! All of this cheats the drug dealer and puts him out of business. I say "bye-bye" and good riddance. Some cities in California are shining examples of how medical marijuana can be implemented without having a negative impact on the neighborhood. Changing the way we think on this will all take time as we have been so influenced by "the war against drugs" and the general misidentification of "pot" as a dangerous narcotic or "class I (or schedule I) substance". Those classifications belong on heroin and morphine. Scientists now know better and are starting to publish their findings. Anyone who has smoked marijuana and has had a demerol injection (I've had both) knows the difference. Demerol is a narcotic pain reliever that is addictive with a whole list of side effects. Please, let's get real. Future leaders, please promote real information. The truth both pro and con. Real stories of real people and some real testing on this God given plant. (You would be shocked to learn how much "real testing" such as double blind studies have NOT been allowed.) Let's not have not rhetoric or misguided politics. Show people in pain some compassion, would you? You might be in the hospital next door to my room one day wishing you had an alternative to some expensive constipating pain pills, shots or that drip in your IV. "

    eric a voth is he a dispicable profiteer in human misery? wrote on May 8, 2007 7:40 PM:

    " you can bet any one who is against medical marijuana ,is profiting from prohabition one way or other "

    eric a voth is a dispicable profiteer in human misery wrote on May 8, 2007 7:36 PM:

    " you can bet any one who is against medical marijuana ,is profiting from prohabition one way or other "

    RevGreen wrote on May 8, 2007 7:05 PM:

    " I pitty those who object to medical cannabis until they, or a loved one is diagnosed with Cancer,MS,RA,Chrohn's Disease,Alzhiemers and suffers nasuea, stomach ailmants suffering side effects listed at the end of every TV drug commercial from current medical treatments(chemo,pain killers,steroids), maybe you'll discover that if you only read the science, medical and successful patient testimonials, as well as giving us longevity of life, you'll know the truth. www.immly.org www.nicerIA.blogspot.com "

    fredamae wrote on May 8, 2007 12:04 PM:

    " STOP THE LIES ABOUT CANNABIS MEDICINE why are drug companies lined up with patents to use cannabis in med preparations they plan to market? explain why drug companies are marketing inhalers with medicine dosages held within the container? with inhaled medicine, you get much faster action. you cannot "standardize" anything as one size never fits all. As an OMMP patient in Oregon, this HERBAL alternative works for my pain without causing nausea, stomach cramping and the "dullness of thought" . the only alternative i could use causes liver failure, high blood pressure and increased heart attack risk. at 60 years old i dont need those risks. cannabis is an effective, viable medicine in its natural form. you don’t die from the side effects. shame on those who refuse to help relieve suffering for those who need it. "

    fredamae wrote on May 8, 2007 11:52 AM:

    " "Eric A. Voth MD Chairman" STOP THE LIES ABOUT CANNABIS MEDICINE why are drug companies lined up with patents to use cannabis in med preparations they plan to market? explain why drug companies are marketing inhalers with medicine dosages held within the container? inhaled medicine/quicker relief. you cannot "standardize" anything as one size never fits all. As an OMMP patient in Oregon, this HERBAL alternative works for my pain without causing nausea, stomach cramping and the "dullness of thought" . the only alternative i could use causes liver failure, high blood pressure and increased heart attack risk. at 60 years old, i dont need any of those risks. cannabis is an effective, viable medicine in its natural form. you don’t die from the side effects. shame on those who refuse to help relieve suffering for those who need it. "

    MidnightToker wrote on May 8, 2007 11:08 AM:

    " Like the Iraq War, the War on Drugs is a failure. The Nation has been at war with drugs since the 70's. What is the current status of the War. We are loosing the war. Political Thinking is so "LAST CENTURY" ! We need responsible change. Legislation in your state if approved would increase LEGAL ACCESS to medical grade marijuana. But it would not increase abuse and increase crime. It is proven in the states that have legalized Medical Cannabis that Use and Abuse have decreased. And Crime has decreased. If you Legalize and Tax, the criminal element is removed. Medical Doctors prescribe medical dosages which are documented. It is time to rethink the current laws and get a Federal Managed Drug program that collects money instead of spending money. "

    David Guard wrote on May 8, 2007 11:01 AM:

    " Steiner and Voth are well-known drug war apologists. Google their names to find out why they seem so uninformed -- they make careers out of staying ignorant, or at least appearing that way as they spread misinformation. A great website with all the facts that allows the reader to access all the science and arguments is http://www.medicalmarijuanaprocon.org/. Read it and decide for yourselves. Subscribe to Drug War Chronicle to stay informed of all drug policy developments at http://stopthedrugwar.org/. "

    independent wrote on May 8, 2007 10:35 AM:

    " And the final insult? SMOKING A MEDICINE? Vaporizers have long been available whereby the byproducts of combustion are avoided. There was a study cited within the last week regarding the effectiveness and safety of vaporizing cannabis. Additionally, a study in the last month or so found that cannabis is actually protective to the lungs against lung cancer and that cannabis smokers had lower rates of lung cancer than even non smokers. But why would I have to try to educate an MD? Oh, it may be that that MD is in the pocket of those with a financial interest in perpetuating this anti-medical cannabis madness. "

    independent wrote on May 8, 2007 10:34 AM:

    " As for bypassing the FDA, big deal. They've had plenty of black eyes in the past couple years. Cannabis is a much more an herb than it is a toxic, synthetic drug with dangerous side effects and lethal dosages. Maybe the FDA can focus on those pharmaceuticals instead. Pot is pure....pure cannabis flowers and as for variable THC levels, there are additional compounds in cannabis such as CBD that are a part of the therapeutic component. The dosage titration is easy to accomplish and there is no lethal dosage or overdose. There has never been and will never be a lethal dose of cannabis. This is something that Aspirin and many other over the counter medicines cannot claim. There have been numerous studies showing the clinical benefits and advantages to cannabis as a therapeutic agent. "

    Oregon Medical Marijuana Patient wrote on May 8, 2007 10:08 AM:

    " There have been several state-sponsored studies of smoked marijuana and all found that it is more effective for nausea than any anti-emetic available from the pharmacy. See: www.medmjscience.org. In Oregon there are many different non-smoked methods of ingestion currently in use including cannabis butter which is usually made into candies, there are lotions, topical oils for massage, tinctures, elixers, and vaporizers. All of these are made by people in their own kitchens. I like the fact that I grow my own medicine and process it myself because I know exactly what went into it. My garden meets OMRI standards for organic gardening. After 14 years of cancer treatment, I can say that I have seen a very clear benefit to using marijuana over conventional drugs that left me incapacitated and blacking out for days at a time. "

    Heil! wrote on May 8, 2007 9:31 AM:

    " "This is a free country. You are free to do what we tell you to do." Signed, your Government. "

    Re: Eric A. Voth MD Chairman, The Institute on Global Drug Policy wrote on May 8, 2007 9:26 AM:

    " It scares me that a person in your position is so uninformed regarding medical marijuana. THC can be dispensed in a variety of forms; pill, food and smoking it. I don't think terminally ill patients need to worry about the risks associated with smoking it. The purity of marijuana can be measured and regulated. Plus, nobody has EVER overdosed on THC. In fact, leading researchers on this issue say that government regulation of drugs will ensure its purity. Where did you go to medical school? "

    Nick wrote on May 8, 2007 9:20 AM:

    " I think some of the critics of medical marijuana are simply uninformed. There is a mass hysteria about marijuana. I have been to Amsterdam. It's not a bad city, and people don't walk around committing crimes and being junkies. But marijuana (and hemp) can provide unique opportunities for America. There are countless claims that marijuana has *greatly* improved the lives of AIDS patients. http://www.spikedhumor.com/Default.aspx?p=search&query=penn%20teller%20war%20on%20drugs&media=0&time=0&title=true&tag=false&description=false Check these videos out for a good demonstration on the positive possibilities on legalizing marijuana. Thanks "

    Frank Schnurstein wrote on May 8, 2007 9:17 AM:

    " I am a conservative Republican and did not take any issue with the WDN comments. If most drugs are made from plants, why isn't research being done to make a pill from MJ that can be tested and finally approved by the FDA. A lot of nay-saying on the issue but think about those that could benefit from it's pain relieving affects. These people are not partiers, they are usually dying a slow and painful death. If you can lace baked goods with MJ, you should be able to make a pill that isn't smoked! "

    Sanfi74 wrote on May 8, 2007 8:45 AM:

    " It's nice to the WDN take such a progressive stance. I certainly understand the concerns of those who oppose medical marijuana, but feel that legalizing it will give doctors another tool to help their patients manage their pain, increase appetite, etc. "

    Eric A. Voth MD Chairman, The Institute on Global Drug Policy wrote on May 8, 2007 7:41 AM:

    " The medical excuse marijuana movement bypasses the FDA and is a serious risk to consumer protection. Pot is impure, THC levels are imprecise, and there is NOT a clear benefit over legitimate medicines. Besides, why would we encourage SMOKING A MEDICINE? "

    Steven H Steiner "AFDFY" wrote on May 8, 2007 6:10 AM:

    " Your Editorial says: Quote “For too long, opponents of the medical marijuana debate have confused it with the War on Drugs. But medical marijuana has nothing to do with illicit drug use” Your all dead wrong… Watch this “You Tube” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mu6Y5Q4tJ-Q http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GgMI-J5EoTc And you attack on Republicans is uncalled for http://www.sorosmonitor.com/money.aspx Click on Minnesota to see how much money was given to Democratic party to influence Medical Pot Steven H Steiner "

    Finally some common ground with the WDN Editorial staff (V. Gallo) wrote on May 8, 2007 12:20 AM:

    " Wow, very nice piece of writing. Please note however that not all of us conservatives feel the same way or should be characterized as the legislators you referred to in your wring. "


    The comments above are from readers. In no way do they represent the views of the Winona Daily News.

     Post a comment (150 word limit) »

    Click here to report offensive or inappropriate comments. Please identify the comment you're concerned about, the story to which the comment was attached, the date of the comment and the person who made the post. Send comments to jerome.christenson@lee.net

    We reserve the right not to post reader comments containing racial, religious or personal attacks, slander, profanity, e-mail addresses, mailing addresses, phone numbers or Web site addresses that are for personal or promotional gain.
    Log In - If you have already signed up with winonadailynews.com, please sign in now!
    *Member ID:
    *Password:
      Forgot Your Password?
     
    Sign Up - To encourage intelligent and meaningful conversation, winonadailynews.com requires all commenters to register before posting comments. It's quick, it's easy, and it's free! Just fill in the information below to get started!

    **Your Member ID and password will be required to log in. Your comments will appear under your user name.

    Do not use usernames or passwords from your financial accounts!

    Note: Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required!

    *Create a Member ID:
    *Choose a password:
    *Re-enter password:
    *E-mail Address:
    *Year of Birth:
     

    (children under 13 cannot register)

    *First Name:
    *Last Name:
    Company:
    Home Phone:
    Business Phone:
    *Address:
    *City:
    *State:
    *Zip Code:
     

    NEWSPAPER ADS

    WINONA JOBS

    TOP HOMES

     
     
    Dailies
    La Crosse Tribune
    Winona Daily News

    Weeklies
    Coulee News
    The Chronicle
    Holmen Courier
    Houston County News
    Onalaska Life
    Tomah Journal
    Vernon Broadcaster
    Westby Times

    Regional
    Inside Preps
    My LIVE! Entertainment
    Best of River Valley
    Business Report
    Healthy Living Today
    Strictly Golf
    River Valley Bike Trails
    River Valley Blogs
    River Valley Outdoors

    Shoppers
    Tri-County Foxxy

    Marketplace
    Newspaper Ads
    Local Website Directory
    7 Rivers Rentals
    HomeSeller
    Wheels Website
    Work For You

    Portals
    La Crosse NET
    Winona NET

    Classifieds
    River Valley Classifieds

    Links
    Lee Enterprises

    About Us | Classifieds | Contact Us | Terms of Use | F.A.Q. | Privacy Policy | Requests | Search | RSS | Videos | Advertiser Directory | Add to My Yahoo!
    Copyright © 1997 - 2008 The Winona Daily News. All rights reserved.
    Material from this site may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or distributed. A Lee Enterprises subsidiary.